Baselining AI visibility for a 30-company portfolio: scope and cost
Baseline AI visibility for a 30-company cohort with one shared prompt set, five AI engines and sector peers, at a fraction of the cost of 30 separate audits.
One of 53 criteria in AEO Rank, the citation-readiness score we run against every site we audit.
Audit Note
In our audits, we've measured Baselining AI visibility for a 30-company portfolio: scope and cost on live sites, we've compared implementations, and we've audited the gaps that keep scores low.
Summarize This Article With AI
Open this article in your preferred AI engine for an instant summary and analysis.
Quick Answer
An accelerator can baseline all 30 companies with one frozen prompt set run across the same five AI engines, then judge each company against its sector peers instead of commissioning 30 separate audits.
That costs a fraction of 30 audits and makes the cohort comparable. My co-founder Alex has spent 20 years building enterprise systems, and together we bring 40+ years of SEO and content infrastructure experience to AEO. I still do not trust a number measured two ways. Neither should a board.
Key Points
- Alexander Stahl's one-afternoon audit tests 20 prompts in 3 assistants, giving 60 rows; his sample slide shows a brand named in 16 of 60 tests, a 27% mention rate.
- In Maddy Osman's November 2025 roundup for Zapier, the cheapest tracker plan was listed at $29 a month, with Claude, Gemini and Google AI Mode costing extra.
- AEO Content's AEO Rank scores each site on 53 criteria across 5 pillars, drawing on 26,577 audits of more than 11,000 domains across 15 sectors.
One cohort, one prompt set, one sheet: the baseline starts with all 30 companies on the same table.
AI visibility happens in three stages: being found, being cited, and being recommended by an assistant such as ChatGPT or Perplexity. Any 30-company cohort will have companies stuck at each stage, often sitting next to each other at demo day.
That spread is the part nobody budgets for. The usual move is to hand every founder a login and wait for 30 exports, none of which looks at Reddit, which one performance marketer calls one of the most important platforms since Google began favoring user-generated content. Then someone has to compare them. It is like assembling a crib from two different boxes. It goes together. Nobody should sleep in it.
I came to this from operations, not marketing. LiveHelpNow, the customer-service company I founded, was an Inc. 5000 inductee at number 84 between 2015 and 2018, and the lesson that stuck was a dull one: you cannot manage something you measure 30 different ways.
The AEO Rank in this article comes from our own audit record, which spans sectors, so each company here gets judged against its own peers instead of one universal grade. A fintech tool and a roofing company should not be graded on the same curve. They would both lose, just differently.
What follows covers what "baselined" actually means when 30 companies share one framework, what that costs next to 30 separate audits, when an agency beats a self-serve tool, and what an operator can get done before Friday.
A software engineer who tested about a dozen AI visibility tools found that every one of them only monitored brand mentions, and none recommended fixes or checked whether a fix worked.
Now picture that times thirty. An accelerator with a 30-company cohort hears the same question from every founder in the same week, roughly why ChatGPT has never heard of them, and the instinct is to buy each founder an audit. Thirty audits. Possibly thirty vendors. And not one of them answering the only question a founder actually asks, which is whether the citations move: for our client Understood Care, Google AI Overview citations rose 500%, from 22 to 132, in about five months.
The decision is simpler than that, and cheaper. Measure the cohort once, with one shared prompt framework across ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews and Gemini, and compare each company with its own sector rather than with whoever shares its demo day. Measurement is no longer the costly part. One self-paced AI visibility course sells for 47 euro and claims it can be finished in one or two weeks.
The costly part is what happens after the report. I would rather see an accelerator spend on the companies that need fixing than on thirty dashboards, each opened exactly once, by the founder's mother.
What does "baselined" mean when 30 companies share one framework?
A cohort baseline runs one fixed prompt set across ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews, then scores each site on our AEO Rank standard: 53 criteria across 5 pillars.
Before anyone talks about cost, the accelerator has to decide what the word baselined means. Otherwise 30 founders will each define it on their own, and you will receive 30 definitions, two of which involve a screenshot taken on a phone at a stoplight.
- Write 15-20 high-intent prompts per company in three buckets: category discovery questions, comparison questions that place the company next to 3 named competitors, and validation questions about the company itself.
- Freeze the wording. Every company in a sector gets the same template, and nobody edits it between runs.
- Run each prompt 5 times in a clean, logged-out session. A company that appears in only 1 of 5 runs has weak grounding, meaning the material the engine reads about it is thin.
- Log the same five fields every time: mentioned or not, position in the answer, how the company is described, which URLs were cited, and which competitors appeared.
- Cover several engines, not one. A single-engine tracker shows one slice of where buyers actually ask.
The five fields come from Alexander Stahl of Simple AI, who published a method for running a first baseline in one afternoon with free tools. His version tests 20 prompts in 3 assistants, which produces 60 rows, and his sample slide reports 16 of 60 tests including the brand, or 27% visibility. He recommends repeating it every quarter. That works nicely for one brand. For thirty, the spreadsheet stays the same and only the afternoons multiply, which is the sort of thing nobody mentions until the intern quits.
The common assumption is that a baseline is a snapshot. It is closer to an average. Answers drift between runs, so the repeated passes are what turn a lucky mention into a rate you can compare across companies.
My own view is that a single screenshot of a chatbot answer belongs in the same drawer as a horoscope. It is specific. It is confident. And it is true, at best, for the afternoon you took it.
The owner of AI Find Me, interviewed on the Jana Talk podcast, treats being found, being cited and being recommended as separate stages, so each company's row in the log can carry three outcomes instead of one. That split earns its place in a cohort report. A company that is found but never recommended has a different problem from one the engines have never heard of, and a shared log shows which is which without anyone having to guess.
A comparison of 4 sources shows the same core: a fixed set, repeated runs, more than one engine and a log with identical fields. Our audits add the site-side half, scoring every company against the same criteria so a weak mention rate can be traced to a cause instead of a mood. Founders who need the vocabulary first can start with the AEO FAQ on AI search optimization before anyone opens a spreadsheet.
Once the definition is frozen, the next argument is about money, and it usually opens with someone asking how many tool seats 30 companies would need.
What does it cost to baseline 30 companies, and what does each option cover?
The listed options span budget per-company trackers, SEO suite add-ons, custom enterprise platforms and one shared cohort framework; choose by what each option covered, not by its sticker price.
Start with the seat math, because that is where most accelerators start, usually on a Friday. In 2025, the vendors' own listed entry prices ran from $29 a month for a budget tracker covering 15 prompts, to $95 a month for a tool tracking three engines in its baseline plans, to a $199-a-month add-on for an existing SEO suite. At the top, one all-in-one enterprise platform listed custom pricing in 2025 from $15,000 a month. None of those numbers is alarming on its own. Multiply any of them by 30 and the line item stops being a rounding error and starts being a conversation with the partners.
| Option | What it covered, as listed | Listed price | Comparable across 30 companies? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Budget per-company tracker | 15 prompts daily on Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Perplexity and Microsoft Copilot; Claude, Gemini and AI Mode sold as add-ons | From $29/month per seat (2025) | Only if every founder buys the same tool and the same add-ons |
| Mid-tier tracker | Three engines in baseline plans | From $95/month (2025) | Same problem, one engine fewer |
| SEO suite add-on | AI visibility bolted onto an existing SEO subscription | From $199/month (2025) | Only for companies already on that suite |
| Enterprise platform | All-in-one tracking and benchmarking | Custom, from $15,000/month (2025) | Yes, though built for one large brand portfolio |
| One shared cohort framework | One prompt set, several engines, sector peer sets, one report | Quoted per cohort | Yes, by design |
The coverage column matters more than the price column. The cheapest plans sold Claude and Gemini as extras, and one competing vendor's comparison page says a popular budget tracker covers only ChatGPT and Perplexity. So ask what 30 founders on 30 entry plans would each be buying, engine by engine, before anyone signs. Then ask which of those engines each company's buyers actually use, because an engine nobody in the sector asks is a line item, not a measurement.
A tool roundup on Reddit's r/SEO_tools_reviews describes Profound as the enterprise option, built for broad competitive benchmarking across many categories, and warns it "might be overkill" for teams that need straightforward insights. The same thread concludes there is "no clear winner yet." One commenter simply calls Clarico.ai "the cheapest I could find," without a price, which tells you something about how buyers are shopping.
I find the trade-off almost endearing. The cheaper the tool, the more of the work it hands back to you, like a dishwasher that only rinses.
Multi-site pricing is not settled either. In an r/SaaS thread, a software engineer who tested about a dozen AI visibility tools lists pricing for agencies managing 20+ sites as unsolved, and a manual auditor in the replies says agencies expect per-site pricing with volume breaks. For an accelerator, that is the opening for negotiation. Ask, too, whether the quote covers the fixes or only the report, because a baseline with no remediation budget is a very expensive thermometer. Whatever the framework saves belongs in the fixes, such as research-driven content built on evidence, and that raises the question founders actually ask next: how much does answer engine optimization cost per month once someone has to do the work?
Why don't 30 separate tool seats add up to one cohort baseline?
Fifteen prompts a day. That is all the cheapest plan in one 2025 roundup of AI visibility tools tracks, and it happens to be where one practitioner's recipe for a believable baseline starts.
Maddy Osman, an SEO and GEO practitioner, wrote the roundup for Zapier in November 2025. She lists that plan at $29 a month. The price covers Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Perplexity and Microsoft Copilot. Claude, Gemini and Google AI Mode cost extra, and unlimited optimization recommendations start at a $189 tier. Osman also spells out what pushes any tool's bill higher: the cost per prompt, how often prompts run, how many engines are tracked and which regions are targeted.
Each of those levers exists for a reason. Answer engines rarely say the same thing twice. "The same prompt on the same answer engine at the same time can still produce variations in responses," Osman writes. In a February 2026 Reddit thread for software founders, one participant was blunter: a single screenshot is "basically useless data." The fix is repetition, but the recipes on offer vary widely. The founder of one visibility scoring tool, who called himself "obviously biased," suggested 15 to 20 prompts run five times each. Another commenter recommended a fixed set of 50 to 200 prompts run every week, logging whether the brand appears, where it ranks, the sentiment and which competitors show up.
Whichever recipe you pick, the method underneath is simple enough to share. Alexander Stahl, a consultant who has advised small businesses in German-speaking Europe since 2023, describes a baseline that fits into one afternoon. He tests 20 prompts in ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity, which gives 60 rows in a spreadsheet. Each row records whether the brand is mentioned, its position, how the answer frames it, which URLs are cited and which competitors appear. His sample slide shows a brand named in 16 of 60 tests, a 27% mention rate, and he suggests repeating the audit every quarter.
Designing the protocol takes an afternoon. The cost comes from scaling it. At the top of its range, the weekly recipe collects twice as many answers in one week as the five-run recipe needs for a whole baseline. An accelerator should settle that choice once, before comparing anyone's price, because every quote will grow with it.
Then there is the question of which engines count. Put the three setups described so far next to each other and they have only two engines in common.
| Engine | Entry plan in the 2025 roundup | Stahl's afternoon audit | Our AEO Rank tracking |
|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | Included | Used | Tracked |
| Perplexity | Included | Used | Tracked |
| Google AI Overviews | Included | Not used | Tracked |
| Microsoft Copilot | Included | Not used | Not tracked |
| Claude | Extra cost | Not used | Tracked |
| Gemini | Extra cost | Used | Not tracked |
| Google AI Mode | Extra cost | Not used | Not tracked |
Another tool in Osman's roundup tracks only three engines on its baseline plans. Osman herself concedes that "no app checks every single box quite yet." If 30 companies each chose their own tool, each would be measured on a different set of engines, and their scores could not be ranked side by side.
The people building these tools say the portfolio case is still open. In a March 2026 Reddit thread, a software engineer who had tested about a dozen visibility tools listed pricing for agencies managing 20+ sites among the problems still unsolved. A commenter who runs manual audits replied that agencies expect "per-site pricing with volume breaks." A shared framework also needs a fair point of comparison. We have scored more than 11,000 domains across 15 sectors and 28 categories, in 26,577 audits so far. That lets each company's result sit beside peers in its own sector, rather than beside a cohort mate in an unrelated market.
Prompts, runs and engines are the levers that raise the price of a seat. They are also exactly what a fair comparison needs held steady from one company to the next. Thirty seats let thirty companies set those levers differently, so extra spending buys more measurements that never line up. One fixed setup, judged against sector peers, turns the same spending into a single dataset an accelerator can actually read.
- Before pricing any seat, list which engines its base plan covers and which cost extra.
- Ask whether an entry price includes recommendations or only monitoring.
- Settle prompts × runs × engines × 30 companies on paper before requesting quotes, then ask every vendor to price that exact volume.
- Give every company the same log columns: mention, position, framing, cited URLs and competitors named.
- Ask any provider, us included, how pricing works beyond 20 sites and which sector benchmark each company will be compared with.
How we checked this
We drew on a published roundup of AI visibility tools, a practitioner's step-by-step audit guide, two Reddit discussions among software founders and tool builders, and our own scoring figures. The audit counts, domain counts and the engines in our tracking are ours.
The answer volumes for 30 companies are our own arithmetic. They assume four engines for the repeat recipes. Zapier earns affiliate commissions from some of the tools it reviews, and its prices date from November 2025, so they may have changed. One Reddit recipe comes from a tool founder who disclosed his bias. The weekly recipe came from a commenter who linked to a company blog.
We sell cohort baselining, so we have a stake in this answer. Still unknown: none of these sources tested how many prompts or runs it takes for a score to hold steady.
- Maddy Osman for Zapier, roundup of AI visibility tools, November 2025.
- Reddit r/SaaS, thread on measuring AI search visibility, February 2026.
- Alexander Stahl, guide to a one-afternoon AI visibility audit, December 2025.
- Reddit r/SaaS, thread on monitoring-only visibility tools, March 2026.
- AEO Content, audit and domain scoring figures, November 2026.
Should I hire an AEO agency or use a self-serve AI visibility monitoring tool?
Give self-serve tools to companies already near their sector peers; bring in a specialist for companies far behind, ideally one that guarantees being named in AI answers within 100 days.
The baseline does one useful, slightly cruel thing. It sorts your cohort. Some companies sit close to their sector peers and need only to keep an eye on things. Others are invisible, and watching an invisible company more closely does not make it visible. It just makes the watching more precise.
- Rank every company by its gap to its sector peers on the shared prompt set, not by its raw mention rate.
- Hand the small-gap companies a self-serve tracker running the same frozen prompts, and make the founder the owner of the rerun.
- Move the large-gap companies to execution. Someone has to rewrite pages, add the missing proof and earn mentions on the sites engines already trust.
- Tie any specialist to an outcome measured on the same prompts, with the date written down, rather than to a count of deliverables.
A monitoring tool on a far-behind company works like a smoke alarm that reports the fire and then waits politely for further instructions. I would not spend cohort money on that. I would spend it on the companies where somebody is actually going to pick up the hose.
The outcome matters because it is the only thing a partner meeting can check. Our guarantee is written that way on purpose: clients are named in AI answers across their target question set within 100 days, or the team keeps working for free, with no contract and the option to cancel anytime. Whatever vendor you pick, ask for terms in that shape. A named question set, a date, and a consequence if the date passes.
What does movement look like when it works? In our client results, Imagine Dental Arts went from about 5 AI-referred new patients a month to 50, a 900% rise. A dental practice is not a seed-stage SaaS company, and I would not promise a cohort the same curve. The useful part is the shape of the number. It is patients, not impressions, which is the unit a founder will actually defend in a board update.
Some large-gap companies will also need presence on third-party pages faster than organic work can earn it. For those, sponsored listings that AI engines cite are a separate lever, priced and judged separately from the baseline itself.
Either way, the large-gap list is short enough to fund properly once the small-gap companies stop asking for their own audits, and the next question is how to read a fintech company and a home-services company on the same page without either founder feeling ambushed.
What should an accelerator do this week?
Freeze one prompt set this week, run it across all 30 companies, and judge each against its sector; our pilot showed that company self-descriptions and real product screens can disagree.
Sector matters because engines do not grade everyone on the same things. In home improvement, reviews and pricing estimates carry the most weight. A fintech company will be judged on something else entirely, and a cohort average politely hides both.
The tools will keep changing. One commenter on Reddit's r/SEO_tools_reviews said most teams are still mixing manual checks with proxy signals, which I find oddly comforting. Nobody has this solved. A frozen framework you own is worth more than a dashboard you rent.
So, this week: write the prompt buckets for one sector, name the competitors each company should be measured against, and put the rerun dates in the calendar before anyone books a vendor demo. The first run will be humbling. The second is where the budget starts to make sense.
Summarize This Article With AI
Open this article in your preferred AI engine for an instant summary.
Frequently Asked Questions
What else do accelerator operators ask about baselining AI visibility?
Most questions come down to how many prompts to run, how far to trust the answers, and how fast a company can move once the baseline exists.
How many prompts should a cohort baseline use?
Practitioner advice runs as high as a fixed set of 50-200 prompts covering the category and its use cases, rerun weekly. For a cohort, I would start smaller and keep the set frozen. Size matters less than sameness.
Can I trust one manual check in ChatGPT?
No. The same question asked twice can return two different answers, so one screenshot proves very little, even the one taken at a stoplight. Repeated runs show stability, which is the only thing worth reporting to a board.
What is share of voice in AI search?
Share of voice is the portion of tracked prompts where a brand appears, recorded per prompt as mentioned or not, rank in any list, sentiment, and which competitors showed up. It is a trend, not a ranking.
How soon can a portfolio company see results?
For our client Modern Wealth, organic search sessions rose 220% and Google clicks rose 61% within three weeks of the first articles. That was search traffic, not an AI visibility measure. It still arrived faster than most board meetings get scheduled.
How does an accelerator get started?
Reach us through the contact page on aeocontent.ai and ask about the cohort program. Bring the list of 30 companies and their sectors, because the sectors decide which peers each company gets judged against.
Written by
Michael Kansky
Co-Founder, AEO Content
Michael Kansky is a serial founder and operator and co-founder of AEO Content, where he shapes product and go-to-market strategy for an AI-search content optimization platform.
Connect on LinkedIn